Obsolescence usually announces itself — but not in the way we expect. It rarely arrives as dramatic failure. It arrives as persistent, low-grade success: the model keeps working, just well enough to stay trusted, while the world it was built for quietly shifts underneath it. The Pragmatist philosopher John Dewey called this 'arrested inquiry' — the moment when a working solution stops being a probe into reality and becomes a settled habit of mind. Once a mental model produces reliable outputs, we stop asking what it's actually measuring and start treating the output as a fact about the world rather than a compressed guess about it. The practical discipline this points to isn't skepticism of your models — it's tracking their vintage. A model calibrated in a faster-moving environment than the one you're currently operating in will overfit for speed; one calibrated in a slower, more stable environment will underfit for change. Neither failure is visible from inside the model itself. The corrective Dewey pointed to: reactivate the original question the model was built to answer, and ask whether that question is still the right one — or whether the territory has shifted and you're now carrying a brilliant answer to a problem that no longer exists.
Which mental model are you currently most confident in — and what was the world like when you first stress-tested it?
Drawing from American Pragmatism — John Dewey (Logic: The Theory of Inquiry, 1938)
This nugget was crafted for someone else's interests.
Imagine one written just for you, waiting in your inbox every morning.
Get your own daily nudge — freeNo account needed. One email a day. Unsubscribe anytime.
Crafted by Nudgeminder